Tonjevic: Halo's really popular in the mainstream, I'll grant, but it seems that most serious "gamers" who get on forums and so forth (i.e. not Xbox Live people) seems to love to hate it. I'd put this in the opposite category, to be honest, as a game which I thought was pretty fun but that all the internet people hate. It's very rare that I hear a good word said for it in these kinds of circles.
I loved the first one when it came out. It was the reason I bought an xbox. 2 and 3 were horrendous, though, especially 2. I was also 13 years old when the first one came out, so it might just be a case of nostalgia.
Like Labyrinth. Saw it as a kid so I like it today, but its probably is no good.