All right, here's the next one:

Ok, here's another screenshot

Ring Runner?

Correct! For future reference, it's better to Reply when posting an answer since then it's easier to know that a new guess needs to be checked :)

Someone else can have my turn.

I'm always up for having a turn. I love this thread :D

Hint: it's from a game that a lot of people hate.

E.T.

*Slowly hides owned cartidge*

Unlike E.T., this game is on Gog.

Very very wild guess: Hatful Boyfriend? Although it looks more interactive than that. ;)

Nope. I think I'll leave this for a little bit longer. I know people know this game - even if they'd rather forget that it exists...

That kind of sounds like it's a terrible sequel in a well liked series ...

I knew that instantly, but can't be bothered to participate right now.

Don't ask me why, but the image reminded me from the start of some kind of planet classification chart.

Then, after the hint and some other comments I was sure it must be referring to Master of Orion 3. I went to the store page, and voilà. :)