Getcomposted: Time to jump in and give my penny's worth of thoughts.
I wasn't fully aware of AcidFlux's present dominance in this thread until now, and I have actually just traded with him on Thursday/Friday.
I traded my Hitman: Absolution & Terraria for "his" Overlord II and Naval War: Arctic Circle.
Now, I don't mind or care what he does with the games I traded to him - he can redeem them, trade them, sell them, print out covers for them, cover them in jam and stroke them lovingly - they're his games.
But, I do mind if the games I received in turn has bad blood attached to them, so to speak.
If AcidFlux did trade with you for the aforementioned games and you're not happy with me being the ultimate receiver of the games, please PM me, and I'll try to work something out with you. My thoughts on trading - always be up front about the reasons you want a game if it's not for yourself.
FULL DISCLOSURE. If I trade with someone, and I'm trading for a game that someone else wants in exchange for a game I do want, I'll tell the first person I trade with, so that they can make an informed decision and refuse to trade if they wish. The world will not end if they do refuse! I'd also inform the second person where that game came from and that I have permission to trade it on.
I tend not to do this as it's hard work, running around PM'ing all and sundry. ;)
But, to trade a game you got in a GA is a definite no-no. You enter a GA for a game you want for yourself or not at all. You do not trade someone's gift away. It's disrespectful and rude. :(
With all of that said, I don't quite regard AcidFlux as a scammer. He just plays a little too fast and loose with the netiquette of trading.
I would trade with AcidFlux again
if he was up front and honest about the provenance of the games he had to trade, and that he had the informed consent of people if he did trade for them. Otherwise, no.
The whole reason I brought up AcidFlux in the scammer thread is because he was lying and trying to get over on someone. If I gift you a game I don't care if you trade it away, it's a gift do with it what you want. But, when someone takes a game that has been gifted and tries to trade it as one they bought themselves at full price to get a better trade how is that not scamming someone? It's not that he tried to trade the game but that he tried to trade it as a game he bought at full price. Liars and cheats should be avoided, and if you enable them they will just continue being a liar and a cheat.