It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Community
General discussionGOG Mafia #60 - HMSS Spectator(488 posts)(488 posts)
(488 posts)
Pages:
1
2
3
4
5
6
10
15
20
25
30
33
This is my favourite topic
Posted July 30, 2019
avatar
RedFireGaming: Wyrm said that mafia rarely picks strongman. Which could make medic a more compelling choice.
Correction: I said the strongman looks like the weakest choice of the three. You can see where Lift disagrees with me on that topic.
Posted July 30, 2019
Unvote: Roleblocker



Vote: Cop

Vote: Doctor
Posted July 30, 2019
I refresh and already Day 0 is done with.

now if only we were this decisive on Day 1s!
Posted July 30, 2019
pity, GR because of IRL did not have a chance to vote.

Makes me question Flub's hammering (Sorry, flub, but...)
Posted July 30, 2019
also, idk if doc or watcher is better, or which is in the lead and i'm too tired to figure it out.
Posted July 30, 2019
Quickly decided, officers. Well done. We'll send through the administrative details and allow you to begin discussion once we've received confirmation.


Vote Count

Cop - 5 votes (Microfish_1, ZFR, Lifthrasil, trentonlf, flubbucket)
Doctor - 5 votes (Bookwyrm627, RedFireGaming, Microfish_1, PookaMustard, flubbucket)
Watcher - 4 votes (Bookwyrm627, ZFR, Lifthrasil, trentonlf)
Roleblocker - 0 vote
Tracker - 0 votes

Cop and Doctor are tied for most votes.

With 9 players, 5 votes is a majority.

Cop and Doctor have been chosen.

---------------

It is now Night 0. Posting in this thread is not allowed.

---------------
Posted July 30, 2019
A few moments later:

The promotions have been submitted, confirmed, and assigned. Now the real task begins. Find those who oppose this mission and eliminate them.

---------------

It is now Day 1. Posting in this thread is allowed.

The deadline is approximately 7 days from now.

---------------
Posted July 30, 2019
avatar
Bookwyrm627: Vote Watcher
And
Vote Doctor
Question...wouldn't COP be better than watcher? Then said cop could help the rest of us town find scum more easily.

====================================
avatar
ZFR: Are we going to discuss?

Vote: Cop
Vote Watcher

Godfather aside (which is true for every opposite mafia PR; every point for a Town PR has to be made with a stipulation "X mafia PR aside"), cop gives most reliable results, and HSL and bler did make good points on why Watcher can be better than Tracker in this scenario (unlike cop, for tracker to be effective he has to pick the mafioso who does the killing). Doctor is for protection instead of info (I think info is more valuable) and RB also suffers from the fact that you have to pick the right mafioso (and might interfere with town PRs too).
Cop is a good choice but doctor is better imo than watcher as cop can find out enough info given enough "nights" gone by and doctor can protect said cop or other town.

========================================

avatar
Microfish_1: Game, when you get back online in a half-day or so, what do you think?
I think we need cop to sniff out scum and doctor to protect cop/other town if possible(depending on what roles scum get).

==============================

avatar
Microfish_1: pity, GR because of IRL did not have a chance to vote.

Makes me question Flub's hammering (Sorry, flub, but...)
It is odd but the choices were good 7 what I was going to vote for so I err on the side of town for flub(for now).
Posted July 30, 2019
So the question now is, do we do a Follow The Cop?

If scum picked GF, it becomes less useful but still a good strategy. If the picked Strongman, we're screwed.
Posted July 30, 2019
avatar
Bookwyrm627: Vote Watcher
And
Vote Doctor
avatar
GameRager: Question...wouldn't COP be better than watcher? Then said cop could help the rest of us town find scum more easily.
More powerful? Probably. More amusing for me? Not when I feel like first-post-fake-claiming "I'm the doctor and all you guys are losers!".

(I'm not claiming doctor at this point in time)

avatar
ZFR: So the question now is, do we do a Follow The Cop?

If scum picked GF, it becomes less useful but still a good strategy. If the picked Strongman, we're screwed.
So, DID you pick strongman?
Posted July 30, 2019
avatar
ZFR: So the question now is, do we do a Follow The Cop?

If scum picked GF, it becomes less useful but still a good strategy. If the picked Strongman, we're screwed.
avatar
Bookwyrm627: So, DID you pick strongman?
I find this subtle attempt to paint ZFR as scum to be.....disturbing.
Posted July 30, 2019
avatar
ZFR: So the question now is, do we do a Follow The Cop?

If scum picked GF, it becomes less useful but still a good strategy. If the picked Strongman, we're screwed.
avatar
Bookwyrm627: So, DID you pick strongman?
No. Ninja.
Posted July 30, 2019
avatar
Bookwyrm627: So, DID you pick strongman?
avatar
GameRager: I find this subtle attempt to paint ZFR as scum to be.....disturbing.
So how do you feel about his suggestion to Out/Follow the Cop??
Posted July 30, 2019
avatar
GameRager: I find this subtle attempt to paint ZFR as scum to be.....disturbing.
avatar
flubbucket: So how do you feel about his suggestion to Out/Follow the Cop??
I believe only the doctor should need to know(usually/for now) who the cop is, and that could be done with subtle hints if the cop did it and the doc picked up on such.

Dunno if that counts as cryptoclaiming or not, though.
Posted July 30, 2019
avatar
flubbucket: So how do you feel about his suggestion to Out/Follow the Cop??
avatar
GameRager: and that could be done with subtle hints if the cop did it and the doc picked up on such.
er.... no.

Subtle hints could mean Mafia pick it and the Doctor doesn't. There are 2 Mafia after all and just 1 Doctor, so statistically a bigger chance.

We either do Follow The Cop properly or not at all.
Pages:
1
2
3
4
5
6
10
15
20
25
30
33
This is my favourite topic
Community
General discussionGOG Mafia #60 - HMSS Spectator(488 posts)(488 posts)
(488 posts)