CarrionCrow: Let's see...
Resident Evil 4 (still), Paper Sorcerer, Rebel Galaxy, Dark Messiah of Might and Magic, Noctropolis, Castlevania Lords of Shadow, Vampire Bloodlines and Wolf Among Us.
Okay, let's see what random unhelpful nonsense I can come up with.
- Resident Evil 4 (still): Killing zombies, but probably not as good as the originals?
- Paper Sorcerer: Erm... a wizard whose only magic power is paper-craft?
- Rebel Galaxy: Dark Vader destroying those annoying murdering rebels?
- Dark Messiah of Might and Magic: Something to do with the Life of Brian?
- Noctropolis: A game near the top of my to play list with all my other kindly gifted games that I put right at the top for when the mood takes me.
- Castlevania Lords of Shadow: If this is like the old Castlevania, then what is not to like.
- Vampire Bloodlines: I know you really like this game, but also that you have probably played it quite a few times, so maybe play a new game unless you wanted a relaxing replay?
- Wolf Among Us: A slightly interactive movie for people too lazy to watch a proper movie?
Yep, I am that helpful. :-)
Sadly I have not played any of them, so I can't offer any real advice. They are quite different, but from what I have heard they are good for the most part, so hopefully no games you will hate.